MOST RECENT FLORIDA LANDLORD/TENANT CASE LAW UPDATE
The decision in Sharaka v. E & A, Inc., 2014 WL 860304 serves as a harsh reminder to the commercial landlord of the importance of an accurate statutory notice. A commercial landlord that serves a grossly inaccurate statutory notice not only risks the prejudicial dismissal of its eviction action, but risks being subjected to a malicious prosecution action (and an adverse punitive damages award). In Sharaka, the Landlord served a three-day demand notice, and subsequently filed an eviction action based upon a Tenant’s failure to pay outstanding CAM expenses. The Landlord had included past CAM charges for years past, without having properly invoiced the Tenant for the CAM charges – as required by the Lease. After a bench trial and Landlord’s appeal, the courts were in agreement that
(1) Landlord breached the Lease by failing to provide the Tenant with yearly CAM statements in accordance with the Lease,
(2) the statutory three-day demand notice was defective for seeking CAM expenses for which annual statements had not been provided, and
(3) an eviction action cannot stand on an improper three-day demand notice. In turn, the Tenant filed an action for malicious prosecution against the Landlord, claiming that the previous eviction action was filed without probable cause. The Landlord filed a motion for summary judgment, arguing that the ruling on the eviction action did not constitute a bona fide termination of the underlying eviction action, because it was a technical termination based on waiver, rather than a final determination of the merits of the case. The trial court agreed with the Landlord, entered final summary judgment in Landlord’s favor, and Tenant appealed. In reversing the summary judgment in favor of the Landlord, the appellate court determined that a “bona fide termination of the prior litigation” for malicious prosecution purposes means that the prior action was terminated on the merits in a manner that demonstrates the prior suit lacked merit. The court determined that termination of the prior eviction suit upon that basis that Landlord failed to provide a proper three-day demand notice constituted an adverse ruling on the merits. The case was remanded to the trial court, and the Tenant was free to continue its pursuit of malicious prosecution damages against the Landlord.
The publication of our annual corporate responsibility report each year is an exciting time for Kimco — an opportunity to celebrate successes as well as to articulate our vision for the future. Our 2016 report marks many important milestones in our environmental, social, and governance performance.… Read More
Fathers not only hold a special place in our hearts, they?ve also helped mold us into the people we are today. And while one day is simply not enough to celebrate these hardworking and inspiring fathers, it?s our job to make this Father?s Day the best one yet by showering the dads in our lives with immense love and heartfelt gifts.… Read More
Food trucks have become one of the most popular new food trends to hit the market. Their convenience and delicious food make for a great combination to attract foot traffic and serve quick, on-the-go meals to those who stop by.
Whether it?s from college, preschool, or anywhere in between, graduation gives all of us plenty of reason to celebrate. In fact, Americans are expected to spend upwards of $5.4 billion this year on graduation meals, gifts, parties, and more.
While cash is still the most popular gift (56 percent of shoppers look to help students with their graduation transition), retailers across the US are ready to fulfill all of your graduation needs.… Read More
One of the best aspects of being the property manager at a shopping center is having the opportunity to interact with guests, boost foot traffic, and create loyal shoppers by hosting creative events. It takes many months of planning, a patient mindset, and nimble thinking, but the joy it brings to community members and tenants makes all the preparation worthwhile.… Read More
Not long ago Harrisburg East Shopping Center was a struggling asset along an incredibly busy corridor east of Harrisburg, in South Central Pennsylvania. The shopping center, while strategically positioned in a retail hub of Harrisburg, needed a little boost. So, a redevelopment opportunity was conceived and the property was soon gearing up to attract new retailers.… Read More
Feel free to share or republish this REIToon and any others posted on the Kimco REIToons page. If you do so, please include this Creative Commons license:
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.… Read More
An expected 37,000 attendees from 58 countries, 1,200 exhibitors, Shark Tank host Barbara Corcoran, and tennis superstar Serena Williams will be at ICSC?s RECon. With less than a week separating us from the big event, Kimco is preparing to meet Serena by brushing up on real estate terminology, and of course doing some light stretching for what is sure to be a perfect match.… Read More
Copyright 2014 McKenna, McCausland & Murphy, P.A. | All Rights Reserved